Gates Memoir Tests Civilian-Military Rules Of Engagement | WAMU 88.5 - American University Radio

Gates Memoir Tests Civilian-Military Rules Of Engagement

Play associated audio

Former Defense Secretary Robert Gates' new book, Duty, Memoirs of a Secretary at War, paints a picture of a White House suspicious of military leaders and their motives.

In the book, Gates criticizes both President Obama and Vice President Joe Biden over issues like the Afghanistan war. It's a case study of civilian-military tensions that are as old as the Republic.

A President Wary Of Being Boxed In

Gates takes the reader inside the White House, where a debate was on about whether to send more troops to Afghanistan. Senior officers were pushing for tens of thousands more, making their case publicly.

Obama was furious, convinced they were trying to box him in.

"Do they resent me that I never served in the military?" Obama says, according to Gates. "Do they think that because I'm young I don't see what they're doing?"

That quote doesn't speak highly of the president, said retired Colonel Pete Mansoor, an Iraq war veteran who worked closely with Gen. David Petraeus. Mansoor now teaches at Ohio State.

"To think that the military was purposely trying to jam him means that he knows very little about military leaders," Mansoor says. "They were giving their best military advice."

But the Pentagon brass have never been shy about pushing its own agenda in Washington — everything from policy issues to weapons systems — even with presidents who were veterans.

Peter Feaver, who served on the White House National Security Council under both Presidents Clinton and George W. Bush, says the Obama administration's suspicion of the military is not surprising.

"When you have Democrats coming in, that can be intensified because of the perception that the military as an institution leans in the Republican, conservative direction," Feaver says.

A Historically Strained Relationship

That suspicion and tension has a long history. Lincoln was openly belittled by his Army commander George McLellan, and he later fired him. Harry Truman famously dismissed Gen. Douglas MacArthur for insubordination.

Richard Kohn, who studies civilian-military relations at the University of North Carolina Chapel Hill, says as the military has modernized, so too has the wariness of civilian leaders.

"Rarely have administrations come in since World War II without some suspicions of the military, their power, their influence, the senior people's desire to shape the outcome of decisions and policies," he says.

Kohn says he's surprised that Gates would come out with a book now. The norm in Washington is to hold off writing a book until a president leaves office.

"It speaks of something of a betrayal of trust," Kohn says. "It simply weakens the president, and if Mr. Gates wants to serve the military he loves, he wouldn't weaken its loyalty and its ability to do its duty for this commander-in-chief for the next three years."

A Deficit Of Trust

For his part, Gates says he didn't want to wait until Obama's term is up in 2017. He says too many issues need more immediate attention.

"Certainly, he's raised fair criticisms that should be aired," Feaver says. Yet the book will only lead the Obama administration to be more wary of the military, he adds.

"Because now they're looking at everyone else in the room, and wondering who should they leave out of the room because that person might be in the process of writing a savage critique of them," he says.

Gates acknowledges in his book that the civilian-military relationship is often tense. He criticizes admirals and generals who seek what he calls "a high public profile," talking too much about politically sensitive issues. Gates can't imagine why they tweet and blog.

But he faults political leaders for using the military as props to sell their own policies, knowing those in uniform are popular with the public.

Politicians, even in the White House, he writes, can't have it both ways.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit

WAMU 88.5

Audiences Get A Modern Look At A 19th Century Opera

Opera as seen through the lens of Google Glass? Wolf Trap is giving audiences the chance to mix technology with Bizet’s classic "Carmen" this month.

The Epic 2,200-Mile Tour De France Is Also A Test Of Epic Eating

Tour de France cyclists need to eat up to 9,000 calories a day to maintain their health and weight during the race. But many teams hire chefs to elevate the meals to gourmet status.

Glenn Beck Takes His Campaign Against Common Core To The Big Screen

Conservative commentator Glenn Beck hosted a live, interactive "night of action" against the Common Core State Standards. He has long fought against the learning benchmarks in reading and math now being used in 43 states. Events such as these, and the Common Core itself, could continue to play a role in the 2014 midterm campaigns.

A Plan To Untangle Our Digital Lives After We're Gone

In the digital age, our online accounts don't die with us. A proposed law might determine what does happen to them. But the tech industry warns the measure could threaten the privacy of the deceased.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.