Filed Under:

High Court's Decision On Federal Marriage Law Has Tax Implications

Play associated audio

When advocates for gay marriage talk about it, they usually focus on the struggle for equality and civil rights.

But how the Supreme Court decides the Defense of Marriage Act case being argued this week could possibly have big implications in another arena — the money same-sex couples owe the Internal Revenue Service.

The case that could throw out a law that defines marriage as between a man and woman started with a tax bill.

Edie Windsor married her partner of more than 40 years in Canada in 2007. Their relationship was recognized by the state of New York, where they lived together. But when her spouse died two years later, Windsor inherited a huge estate tax bill — a bill she would have avoided if her marriage had been recognized under federal law.

Gay Couples Plan Ahead

"The big thing that people need to be aware of is that you have to actively plan if you're LGBT in your estate or individual taxes, because the law is not set up to protect you," says Nanette Lee Miller, an accountant who works with gay and lesbian clients.

Miller says many of those couples are watching the Supreme Court this week for clues about what's in store for their own finances.

They don't get a marital deduction for estate tax purposes, so they usually need access to cash or life insurance to be able to inherit their partner's share of a home or other assets.

That could change, if the high court rules for Windsor and declares the 1996 Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional. In that case, same-sex couples would get the same estate tax benefits as married partners.

Roberton Williams of the Urban Institute in Washington, D.C., says those savings would help just a tiny fraction of people.

"Very, very few people pay estate taxes," he says. "We estimate that with today's exemption level of $5 million, less than two-tenths of 1 percent of deaths result in a taxable estate."

Individual Tax Returns Will Be Affected

A ruling that the entire DOMA law is unconstitutional would have a much bigger impact on individual tax returns — the ones filed by same-sex married couples or registered domestic partners every year.

"If failure to recognize same-sex couples for tax purposes is unconstitutional, then it would be unconstitutional also to insist that it be a man and a woman — husband and wife — who file a joint return," says Patricia Cain, a law professor at Santa Clara University in California.

Cain says the ability for same-sex couples to file taxes jointly will be a mixed bag.

"That's good for some people and bad for others," Cain says. "In other words, you know, we have a marriage bonus when you have a couple with one high earner and one stay-at-home partner or low-income partner. And those people usually experience a tax bonus when they file jointly."

The Good, And The Bad

So, generally, good news for couples whose incomes are wide apart, but bad for some other same-sex couples with roughly similar incomes.

The numbers are complicated, and many couples are asking accountants such as Miller for advice.

She says people who may get some tax benefits if DOMA is overturned are thinking about amending their tax returns for the past three years to try to collect some extra money.

"For individuals you can go back to 2009, 2010, 2011, and you can also file an amended return, or there's a form to fill out in taking advantage of married filing jointly," Miller says.

But she says some clients have been surprised to find out they'll pay the dreaded marriage penalty, and they're not happy.

"They go, 'What, there's a penalty?' " she says.

She says she tells them that's just a price of equality.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

NPR

Once Outlaws, Young Lords Find A Museum Home For Radical Roots

Inspired by the Black Panthers, the Young Lords were formed in New York City by a group of Puerto Rican youth in 1969. Their history is now on display in a new exhibition.
NPR

Europe's Taste For Caviar Is Putting Pressure On A Great Lakes Fish

Scientists say lake herring, a key fish in Lake Superior's food web, is suffering because of mild winters and Europe's appetite for roe. Some say the species may be at risk of "collapse."
WAMU 88.5

A Congressional Attempt To Speed The Development Of Lifesaving Treatments

Earlier this month, the House of Representatives passed the 21st Century Cures Act in a rare bi-partisan effort. The bill is meant to speed the development of lifesaving treatments, but critics warn it may also allow ineffective or even harmful drugs onto the market.

NPR

Some Google Street View Cars Now Track Pollution Levels

Google's already tested three of the pollution-sensor equipped cars in Denver, and is currently trying them out in the Bay Area.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.