Federal Court To Weigh Graphic Cigarette Labels | WAMU 88.5 - American University Radio
Filed Under:

Federal Court To Weigh Graphic Cigarette Labels

Play associated audio

The question of how far the government can go in forcing a business — in this case cigarette makers — to warn consumers about its product is before a federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday.

The Food and Drug Administration wants large, graphic warning labels to scare smokers, but tobacco companies say that violates their right to free speech.

Diseased lungs, gnarly rotting teeth, even what appears to be the corpse of a smoker are some of the images that accompany the bold new cigarette labels the FDA requires to cover half a pack of cigarettes, front and back. The written warnings include: "Smoking Can Kill You" and "Cigarettes Cause Cancer."

"It's going beyond I think what is necessary," says David Hudson, a scholar at the First Amendment Center in Nashville, Tenn. "It's just so in your face, so graphic, these images — it's just simply too much."

That's what Congress intended when it mandated the labels in a 2009 law that gave the FDA the authority to regulate tobacco.

Susan Liss, executive director of the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids, says the idea is to counteract the tobacco industry's track record of misleading smokers.

"We are dealing with an industry with a decades-long history of deceiving the public about the health risks of smoking, and the enhanced warning labels are a direct response to the deception of the industry," Liss says.

Washington, D.C., federal Judge Richard Leon blocked the FDA from implementing the labels, siding with cigarette makers who sued over their right to free speech. The judge questioned whether the government had crossed the line into advocacy by using such graphic images.

The fact that an image is evocative shouldn't matter, says Matt Myers, the president of the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids.

"The picture of somebody that is dying from tobacco can be an accurate representation of the health effects of smoking, even if it evokes an emotional reaction," Myers says.

Tobacco Free Kids and other anti-smoking groups have filed a friend of the court brief with the D.C. appeals court, arguing that the new labels are in line with the FDA's power to warn consumers about dangerous products.

FDA officials and the tobacco companies declined to discuss the case, but it is one being watched by constitutional scholars because of the nation's mixed case law when it comes to protections for commercial speech.

Another federal appeals court has already upheld the cigarette warning labels as constitutional.

George Washington University professor Jonathan Turley says the threshold question is how far the government can go to compel commercial speech.

"These graphic images are really the government getting into marketing and trying to force companies that have lawful products to use repellant packaging," Turley says.

He says other businesses should be paying attention.

"Cigarettes are not the only harmful product," he says. "Can they, for example, require a picture of a cirrhotic liver on a wine bottle or any type of alcoholic beverage?"

The ultimate decision will likely be determined by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

NPR

Fresh Air Weekend: Toni Morrison, Ross Macdonald's Crime Fiction, Will Forte

Nobel laureate Morrison reflects on her life and her regrets; Maureen Corrigan reviews a reissue of four of Macdonald's 1950s novels; SNL alum Forte discusses comedy and Bruce Dern's acting advice.
NPR

PepsiCo Swaps Diet Drink's Aspartame For Other Artificial Sweeteners

The company says Diet Pepsi consumers are concerned about aspartame. But the Food and Drug Administration has long affirmed that the sweetener is safe in amounts commonly used by beverage companies.
NPR

Surgeon General Vivek Murthy On Gun Control, Vaccines And Science

Surgeon General Vivek Murthy was officially sworn in this week. His confirmation was held up for more than a year because of comments he made about gun violence. Murthy talks with NPR's Scott Simon.
NPR

As Health Apps Hop On The Apple Watch, Privacy Will Be Key

The notion of receiving nutrition advice from artificial intelligence on your wrist may seem like science fiction. But health developers are betting this kind of behavior will become the norm.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.