Virginia's Supreme Court Considers Alexandria's Wales Alley Fight | WAMU 88.5 - American University Radio

WAMU 88.5 : News

Filed Under:

Virginia's Supreme Court Considers Alexandria's Wales Alley Fight

Play associated audio
Virtue Feed & Grain, which opened last year in Old Town Alexandria, borders Wales Alley, but there's an ongoing fight over whether they can place tables and chairs for service in that alley.
Thomas Cizauskas (http://www.flickr.com/photos/cizauskas/5821047209/)
Virtue Feed & Grain, which opened last year in Old Town Alexandria, borders Wales Alley, but there's an ongoing fight over whether they can place tables and chairs for service in that alley.

The city of Alexandria and the Old Dominion Boat Club are engaged in a fierce legal battle for control of an alley leading to the waterfront — one that's gone all the way to the Virginia Supreme Court.

Inside the marble-walled chamber of the Virginia Supreme Court, justices are now considering the case. At issue is the use of Wales Alley, a public street named for Andrew Wales who once sold beer there. Boat Club members say they have an easement right to use the alley dating back to a 1789 deed allowing for free use and passage. Lawyers for the city and the restaurant say the government maintains the street and can do what it wants, which includes allowing waterfront restaurant to set up tables and chairs there.

"I think there's good counsel involved all the way around," says Deputy City Attorney Chris Spera. "I think that the court has a full exposition of the issues laid out before it, and we'll see what the court does."

City Council members agreed to lease the alley for use as part of the restaurant Virtue Feed & Grain back in 2010. The Old Dominion Boat Club, which uses the alley to move boats, brought a lawsuit, arguing that the city is violating the right of its members. In April 2011, the Alexandria Circuit Court sided with the boat club and the city appealed the decision. 

The Boat Club has long been at odds with the city, especially over a waterfront parking lot that the city wants to transform into a public park. Last summer, the city threatened to take some of the boat club's land using the power of eminent domain. Now boat club lawyers are arguing in court that what the city has done in Wales Alley is eminent domain by other means.

In this case, the Virtue Restaurant people did not assert a private claim to the alley. Rather, they came to the city acknowledging that it was a public alley and got a license from the city.

Attorneys for the boat club declined to comment.

The court is expected to rule in six to eight weeks

NPR

'Language Of Food' Reveals Mysteries Of Menu Words And Ketchup

Linguist Dan Jurafsky uncovers the fishy origins of ketchup and how it forces us to rethink global history. He also teaches us how to read a menu to figure out how much a restaurant may charge.
NPR

'Language Of Food' Reveals Mysteries Of Menu Words And Ketchup

Linguist Dan Jurafsky uncovers the fishy origins of ketchup and how it forces us to rethink global history. He also teaches us how to read a menu to figure out how much a restaurant may charge.
NPR

Obama To Announce Large Ramp Up Of Ebola Fight

The U.S. military plans to establish a medical base in Liberia to help stop the Ebola epidemic. It will build 1,700 new treatment beds and train up to 500 health care workers every week.
NPR

Minecraft's Business Model: A Video Game That Leaves You Alone

Microsoft is buying the company that created the video game Minecraft, which has a loyal following in part because of the freedom it allows players — including freedom from pressure to buy add-ons.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.