WAMU 88.5 : News

Filed Under:

Commentary: We Can't Keep Spending Money On People Who Make Bad Choices

Play associated audio

Joined by advocates for an ever-expanding welfare state, Judith Sandalow recently lamented the federal government shutdown's impact on the flow of federal dollars to a multitude of nonprofit anti-poverty programs here in the District.

But considering that the nation's current poverty rate of 15 percent is the same as it was in 1966 when Great Society welfare spending was exploding, all taxpayers might fairly ask if the several trillion dollars we've spent since have been wisely spent.

In any case, with or without more political showdowns and shutdowns, I expect tighter federal budgets to continue favoring the elderly over the poor, so those whose lives revolve around anti-poverty programs must learn to make better life-choices if they're to survive and thrive.

As economist David Malpass recently wrote in The Wall Street Journal, the federal government spent $3.6 trillion last fiscal year. Eighty percent of that spending, or roughly $250 billion per month, was for the major entitlements Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. Without substantive entitlement reform, that figure will only increase as 75 million baby boomers grow older.

Meanwhile, Malpass adds, we've already piled up $17 trillion in debt and are on the hook for another $60 trillion in unfunded spending promises over coming decades. Even with historically low interest rates at the moment, we spent nearly $250 billion this year on interest payments alone, while borrowing yet another $1.1 trillion. And all of this ballooning debt will invariably be heaped on to our children, grandchildren and unborn great grandchildren in the form of crushing taxes that will rob them of the educational and economic opportunities many WAMU listeners were fortunate enough to enjoy.

So if we don't initiate significant reductions in government spending very soon, it won't matter whether poor children get the kind of  good start in life that Ms. Sandalow and all the rest of us would like them to get — because there won't be any opportunities waiting for them as young adults. Just look at the catastrophically high unemployment rates for those under 25 in Greece, Portugal and Spain if you want to glimpse the United States possible high-debt, low-growth future.

Fiscal conservatives are not heartless. We care very much about future generations. And we're happy to work with anti-poverty activists to meet the needs of children. But the activists must meet us halfway and begin speaking unvarnished truths about good choices and bad choices.

When low-skill, unwed individuals — men and women — refuse to postpone parenthood until they achieve necessary education and family and financial stability, they irresponsibly impose those choices on both taxpayers and their innocent children. The government can't raise our children. And the politically incorrect reality is that no amount of government spending can end or even significantly reduce childhood poverty as long as millions of Americans insist on having children they can't afford to raise.

Darren McKinney is a D.C. resident.

We want to hear how your background and expertise inform your view of the world. Please join our Public Insight Network and let us know what you think. You can also email us at insight@wamu.org.

 


 

WAMU commentaries come from contributors not on the staff of WAMU 88.5. These articles are not intended to reflect the positions of WAMU 88.5. The commentary page is seen as a forum to air diverse and challenging viewpoints.

Please continue the conversation about this topic in the comment section below.

NPR

In This 2005 Interview, Gene Wilder Explains How He Learned To Get Laughs

When he was 8, Wilder's mother had a heart attack, and he took it upon himself to cheer her up. We'll listen back to a Fresh Air interview with the comic actor, who died Monday at age 83.
NPR

Why California's New Farmworker Overtime Bill May Not Mean Bigger Paychecks

California lawmakers just passed a landmark bill that would make farmworkers eligible for overtime if they work more than eight hours a day or 40 hours a week. Some farmers say they can't afford that.
NPR

Republicans Consider Lasting Impression Of Trump On Their Party

Republicans are debating whether — win or lose — Donald Trump has already altered the DNA of the Republican Party.
NPR

Facebook Faces Trending News Problems After Firing Curators

On Friday, news site Quartz reported that Facebook fired its "news curators" and replaced them with algorithms to compile the news that ends up on Facebook's "Trending" news section. Many users took note when a fake article about Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly was trending.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.