WAMU 88.5 : News

Filed Under:

Cheh Says Proposed Taxicab Rules Would Stifle Innovation

Play associated audio
Uber is among the app-based hailing services that could be affected by a set of rules being proposed by the D.C. Taxicab Commission.
WAMU/Chris Chester
Uber is among the app-based hailing services that could be affected by a set of rules being proposed by the D.C. Taxicab Commission.

The D.C. Taxicab Commission is considering adopting “burdensome” regulations that would “discourage new, innovative technology companies from operating in the District,” according to the D.C. Council member who authored legislation last year to allow app-based hailing services to operate in Washington.

In a letter to the DCTC’s chairman, Council member Mary Cheh (D-Ward 3) cautioned against approving proposed regulations for the new sedan class of vehicle-for-hire services under which tech companies like Uber—one of seven tech companies doing business in D.C.—legally operate.

“Some of them seem heavy handed to me and not necessary, and they may reflect a kind of overly protective approach to something that doesn’t need protection,” said Cheh in an interview with WAMU 88.5.

Specifically, Cheh is concerned with a slew of proposed requirements and restrictions. If adopted at the next DCTC meeting on June 25, “digital dispatch services” operating in the sedan class would have to “provide a detailed technical description to the Commission, including its technical specifications, its software applications, its operating systems and its trade names, all of which are subject to Commission approval,” said Cheh in her letter.

“Although these rules appear well-intentioned, I question the necessity of such a burdensome approval process,” she said.

The proposed rules would also require tech companies provide “an inventory of all drivers and vehicles associated with its service, to produce business records to the Commission over the most-recent five years, and to provide an annual report of all incidents involving payment disputes of $50 or more, fraud or criminal activity, and violation of anti-discrimination regulations.”

Vehicle types would be restricted, too, a move that runs counter to the District’s intention to widen consumer choice, Cheh said. For instance, hybrid vehicles would not qualify as “sedans,” barring Uber from introducing fuel-efficient vehicles into its service.

“The Commission's proposed rules place significant limitations on the type of vehicles that can be used for sedan-class service in the District, including that the vehicle: (i) weighs at least 3,200 pounds, (ii) is fewer than five years old, (iii) is blue or black in color, and (iv) is equipped with luxury features (a premium sound system, reading lights, and aluminum wheels),” Cheh said.

Hailo, mytaxi, Taxi Magic, HitchRides, TaxiRadar, Yellow Cab, and Uber are the seven app-based companies currently operating in Washington. Uber has complained the loudest over the past year about proposed regulations, repeatedly accusing the DCTC of threatening to push it out of Washington. By issuing strongly worded press releases and using social media to rally its customer base, Uber has attempted to pressure elected officials and regulators to back off.

DCTC Chairman Ron Linton declined to comment on the proposals up for consideration on June 25, citing the ongoing regulatory process. “We take comments submitted in writing very seriously and give careful consideration to what is being said,” said Linton in an interview with WAMU 88.5. Changes to the proposed rules by the commission would trigger another 30-day public comment period, he added.

In a statement, Uber’s D.C. general manager Rachel Holt excoriated the DCTC, accusing regulators of imposing barriers to “innovative transportation options.”

Cheh is urging regulators change their perspective on the evolving vehicle-for-hire industry. Instead of crafting regulations for either taxicabs or sedans, the commission should focus on street hails versus app-based hailing, regardless of the kind or size of vehicles being used, Cheh said.

“The rules that are being proposed would eliminate that kind of choice,” she said. “We should have that choice. It will allow Uber and some of these other companies to have hybrid vehicles that may weigh less” than 3,200 pounds.

On another front, Uber and mytaxi contend the required installation of credit card payment machines in all D.C. taxicabs by Sept. 1 threatens their taxi hailing and payments apps. The issue is integration: the apps must work with whichever payment service providers cabbies choose to process credit card payments in their vehicles.

Uber claims integration has never been successfully implemented in any of the 35 cities where the company operates.

In New York, integration is slowing taking shape. An e-hailing pilot program involving the tech company Taxi Magic is underway after the resolution of a legal dispute. Taxi Magic is currently working with New York’s Taxi & Limousine Commission to approve its payment system.

Cheh Letter to Ron Linton


Lisa Lucas Takes The Reins At The National Book Foundation

Lucas is the third executive director in the history of the foundation, which runs the National Book Awards. Her priority? Inclusivity: "Everyone is either a reader or a potential reader," she says.

The Shocking Truth About America's Ethanol Law: It Doesn't Matter (For Now)

Ted Cruz doesn't like the law that requires the use of ethanol in gasoline. So what would happen if it was abolished? The surprising answer: not much, probably.
WAMU 88.5

The Latest on the Military, Political and Humanitarian Crises in Syria

Russia continues airstrikes in Syria. Secretary Kerry meets with world leaders in an attempt to resolve the country’s five-year civil war. A panel joins Diane to discuss the latest on the military, political and humanitarian crises facing Syria.


Should India's Internet Be Free Of Charge, Or Free Of Control?

Facebook's free Internet service was banned in India on the basis of net neutrality this week. Internet providers, regulators say, should not be allowed "to shape the users' Internet experience."

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.