NPR : News

Filed Under:

High Court Upholds Ruling Ordering Removal Of Crosses In Utah

The United States Supreme Court has let stand a lower court ruling that ordered the removal of 12-foot high crosses placed along highways in Utah to commemorate state troopers killed in the line of duty.

The court acted without comment, but Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a 19-page dissent.

Starting in 1998, the private Utah Highway Patrol Association erected and maintained more than a dozen memorial crosses, most on state land, and visible from the highway. The American Atheists Association and three of its Utah members sued the state in 2005, contending that the crosses amounted to state endorsement of religion.

A federal appeals court in Denver agreed, concluding that the cross is "the preeminent symbol of Christianity," and that the crosses "stood alone, on public land, bearing the Utah Highway Patrol emblem."

The Utah Highway Patrol Association appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but by an 8-to-1 vote, the Court declined to review the lower court decision.

The solo dissent came from Justice Clarence Thomas, who has long taken the position that the Constitution's ban on state establishment of religion applies only to the Federal government, and not to the states.

Even if the other justices do not subscribe to that view, he said, they should have taken the Utah case for reivew to straighten out its previous conflicting and "unprincipled" decisions.

Indeed, Thomas said that the Court has made such a muddle of its religious display cases that the lower courts are simply unable to comply. He pointed in particular to two decisions issued by the Supreme Court six years ago. In one, the justices upheld a Ten Commandments monument on state grounds in Texas because it stood with many other kinds of monuments and, in context, was seen as more historical than religious. In the other, the justices ruled that a Kentucky courthouse had to take down its display of the Ten Commandments because of what the justices saw, in context, as a clearly religious message.

Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

NPR

A Compelling Plot Gives Way To Farce In Franzen's Purity

The new novel reveals sharp observations and a great, sprawling story. But critic Roxane Gay says the book gets bogged down with absurdly-drawn characters and misfired critiques of modern life.
NPR

Huge Fish Farm Planned Near San Diego Aims To Fix Seafood Imbalance

The aquaculture project would be the same size as New York's Central Park and produce 11 million pounds of yellowtail and sea bass each year. But some people see it as an aquatic "factory farm."
WAMU 88.5

Europe's Ongoing Migrant And Refugee Crisis And The Future Of Open Borders

The Austria-Hungary border has become the latest pressure point in Europe's ongoing migrant crisis. An update on the huge influx of migrants and refugees from the Middle East and Africa and the future of open borders within the E.U.

WAMU 88.5

Environmental Outlook: How to Build Smarter Transportation And More Livable Cities

A new report says the traffic in the U.S. is the worst it has been in years. Yet, some urban transportation experts say there's reason to be optimistic. They point to revitalized city centers, emerging technology and the investment in alternative methods of transportation. A conversation about how we get around today, and might get around tomorrow.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.