NPR : News

Filed Under:

Financial Conflicts 'Pervasive' On Key Medical Panels

Like it or not, there's a seeming inexorable movement in medicine toward guidelines to help the average doctor deliver care that's in line with the latest evidence.

Somebody has to come up with those guidelines. Somebodies, actually, and they usually are experts who sit on panels charged with the task of boiling down the evidence.

But can the recommendations be trusted? A study just out in the BMJ raises new doubts. Researchers found conflicts of interest were prevalent among experts who served on 14 U.S. and Canadian panels that came up with guidelines for the treatment of diabetes and high cholesterol between 2000 and 2010.

All told, 52 percent (or 150 of 288 people) had financial conflicts of interest. Common issues included speaking gigs paid for by industry and consulting deals. Conflicts were more common on the Canadian panels. Government-sponsored panels had fewer conflicts than those other outfits, such as professional societies.

The study authors conclude:

The finding that most current members of guideline panels and half of chairs of panels have [conflicts of interest] is concerning and suggests that a risk of considerable influence of industry on guideline recommendations exist.

An accompanying editorial goes further, saying the financial incentives for companies to skew the work of panels in their favor is a real danger:

With billions of dollars at stake, a company has every motive to encourage potential guideline panelists to view its product in a favourable light, and a virtually limitless budget to support this objective.

Stop the hand wringing and confront reality, Dr. Edwin Gale, a diabetes specialist from England, writes. Legislation can't fix the problem. Instead, he says, the time has come for a fundamental shift in mores: "What is needed is a change of culture in which serving two masters becomes as socially unacceptable as smoking a cigarette."

Copyright 2011 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

WAMU 88.5

Rita Dove: "Collected Poems: 1974 - 2004"

Rita Dove's poetry career has spanned more than forty years. During that time she won a Pulitzer Prize and became the first African-American poet laureate of the United States. Now she's released a new edition of collected works. Rita Dove on a life lived in verse.

NPR

U.S. To Ship Peanuts To Feed Haitian Kids; Aid Groups Say 'This Is Wrong'

On paper, the USDA's plan to send surplus peanuts to feed 140,000 malnourished Haitian schoolchildren sounds heroic. But aid groups say it could devastate Haiti's peanut farmers.
WAMU 88.5

Back From The Breach: Moving The Federal Workforce Forward

A year after a massive cyber breach compromised the databases of the Office of Personnel Management, Kojo talks with OPM Acting Director Beth Cobert about her agency and key issues facing the federal workforce.

WAMU 88.5

Why Medical Error Is The Third Leading Cause Of Death In The U.S.

New research shows medical error is the third leading cause of death in the U.S., killing more than 250,000 people a year. Why there are so many mistakes, and what can be done to improve patient safety.

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.