Privacy And Free Speech Relationship To Come Before Supreme Court | WAMU 88.5 - American University Radio

: News

Privacy And Free Speech Relationship To Come Before Supreme Court

Play associated audio

By Kavitha Cardoza

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case this fall that involves the rights of a controversial church group that picketed the funeral of a Marine from Maryland's Carroll County who was killed in Iraq, Lance Corporal Matthew Snyder. The case questions the relationship between privacy and free speech.

Protesters from the Westboro Baptist Church held signs during the funeral that read "Thank God For dead soldiers" and "God hates you." They believe God is killing soldiers to punish the United States for accepting homosexuality. Attorney Sean Summers says this devastated the Snyder family.

"You only have one opportunity to bury your son. They essentially tarnished that forever," says Summers.

The family sued for the intentional infliction of emotional distress and invasion of privacy but most recently the 4th circuit U.S. Court of Appeals sided with the Church, citing free speech rights.

Jamie Raskin teaches constitutional law at American University.

"The question basically is whether arriving at a funeral and engaging in hate speech is something that is protected or not," says Raskin.

Raskin says church members were complying with all local laws during the protest so the Supreme Court may uphold the lower court's decision. On the other hand he says this was a private family funeral and the Supreme court has previously ruled private individuals may enjoy greater protections against what he calls "wounding" speech.

"It goes to the question of whether private individuals at a funeral who are subjected to one of these hate protests can sue for intentional infliction of emotional distress," he says.

17 states have signed onto an amicus or "friend of the court" brief in support of the family, including Kansas where the church is based. But Maryland, where the Snyder family lives and Virginia, have not. The brief needs to be filed by Friday.

NPR

Maggie Gyllenhaal Is 'The Honorable Woman': A Series Both Ruthless And Rewarding

The eight-part drama that begins Thursday stars Maggie Gyllenhaal as a British baroness with an Israeli passport. She's a fearless actor in a show full of kidnappings, seductions and betrayals.
NPR

When China Spurns GMO Corn Imports, American Farmers Lose Billions

China has been a big and growing market for U.S. corn. But then farmers started planting a kind of genetically engineered corn that's not yet approved in China, and the Chinese government struck back.
WAMU 88.5

On Cantor's Last Day As House Majority Leader, Debate Surrounds His Legacy

In his last address to colleagues as Majority Leader, Cantor told his colleagues to remember the House's bipartisan accomplishments.
NPR

Can Pinterest Compete With Google's Search?

Pinterest has created a database of things that matter to humans. And with a programming team that's largely been hired away from Google, the company has begun offering what it calls "guided search."

Leave a Comment

Help keep the conversation civil. Please refer to our Terms of Use and Code of Conduct before posting your comments.